Sunday, March 7, 2010

More reflections and personal opinions

The MBA has brought plenty of learnings this far - in terms of working with people here, in terms of understanding my personal strengths and opportunities and in having fun. Some observations that i admire about people here, and some things that i find strange.

My classmates are very results-driven and pragmatic. In typical meetings, every person comes informed and with an attitude of finishing the work right then. There's very little time wasted in explaining or reexamining concepts which have been covered in the assigned reading. My colleagues are interpretive and grasp the concepts needed to get the job done very quickly. Also, they communicate very efficiently, talking facts and solutions. People expect that you are credible and that you mean what you say or hint at. You would be held liable for what you speak. Their listening skills are strong, and people are quick at grasping the slant or implications of the sentences.

From what i have observed, this probably comes from a culture of reading and of implementing ideas. Even when having fun, my friends would have theme parties or play games, all requiring a fairly good grasp of rules. Reading definitely helps sharpen the intellect. Plus this is a culture of confidence where a high premium is put on one's accomplishments and skills, rather than on wealth and social status. I have rarely seen Americans hesitate or talk unclearly, even the not so educated ones. People articulate their ideas and opinions confidently, and often politely. A person is rarely blamed openly, but mostly within confined circles. If something is wrong, nobody would point it out to you, unless they are close friends, and then you would be expected to find a way out of the mess. If people sense that you are not going to improve, then you are excommunicated. One has to be very discrete in expressing personal judgements or opinions and careful about the audience. Courtesies are not as important, but people expect sincerity and a willingness to work and deliver results and to collaborate with them. If all these rules can be observed, you would notice that MBAs are very friendly people :)

The culture is an open culture. As a good friend had pointed out to me once, children here are raised to believe they are superstars and have little restrictions imposed upon them. On the flipside, every person is responsible for his/her own life from a very young age and people start working towards making a mark for themselves from a very young age. Competition is a part of the culture, and people's aim in life seems to expand their personal capabilities to the maximum. Relationships, marriages and other social institutions are considered secondary to this goal. Hence the problems. If you fail, or get weak or screw up, its game over - you lose your 'friends', who are not expected to help you get your act together in the first place. So people lose everything and sometimes they get it all back. Hence, the high stress in society and the fear. People resort to marijuana, to alcohol and to other recreational drugs to 'lose' reality sometimes. It has become such an ingrained part of culture, that the line between dependence and between doing these for fun is blurred. College is supposed to be a phase in a young man/woman's life to have as much 'fun - as many outings and trips and activities and friends and sex and booze as possible. Everything is governed by the WIIFM principle - whats in it for me. It is assumed that selfishness is a person's nature and a person works towards his or her enjoyment, trying to create a personal world perfect with their personal vision of how people, situations and objects should be. However, a lot of respect is accorded a person who gives back to society. The rule for success is get successful first, take care of people and society after that.

This is some of what i have surmised so far from my interactions. Of course, I attend college and hence deal with a more informed, more purposeful group than the general populace, as my friends tell me. Of course a lot of rings close to the stereotypical image we have of the American society but seeing it at the ground level reveals many subtle nuances and differences. Lets see what discoveries the future brings.

6 comments:

AparnA said...

a good friend of mine who is in US doing MS also gave me same response... :) well, being here in India..it sure is quite different.. people like you should bring all these things also along with your degree when you get back home! :)

Unknown said...

yep Aparna, then again it is hard to fit this with a culture of tolerance. People do not tolerate imperfection at all.

komal said...

wow interesting i got to know of the same thing from my cousin in stanford as well .. sounds a lot different from australia which altough was an open culture,people would tell anyone they vaguely know about their feelings and share things.. more like europe or uk alos i do believe that stress and all is so high in the us and some northern european countries because of emphasis on too much individual freedom i feel uk, india and some asian countries are better off because family values and competitive stress is a lot less when comparend to the states .. tolerating imperection? socrates once said beauty lies in the imperections of the humna existence something the americans ive interacted with have never understood in my opinion am sorry but after australia,where people would express their opinions openly but at the beggining of every convo say dont take it 2 heart.. also i do agree that high stress levels do lead to chronic alcoholism,drugs, smoking, etc that sadly is becmong a reality in india today . Thats why a great indian philosoper like swami vivekananda said that the indians need to imbibe only the good values of the west and the west must imbibe the good values of the east only then would it be a harmonious peaceful world. How right he was when we consider todays scenario where the east is imbibing the negative aspects of western values and the west has successfully imbibed the goog values from the east....

Unknown said...

komal that was a very insightful comment! people are firendly and easygoing but within limits and in certain spheres. the culture seems to be more incined towards doing things rather than talking and discussing, possibly due to the college environment. Americans are probably the most outspoken bunch on the planet, but they are very accurate with their descriptions.

GauravNath said...

Very observative post :-)

...makes me feel more grateful that I was born in India...and am into Art Of Living.

These are the precious people in our planet who make us realize that we are living more contented, richer and fuller lives, and bring more gratitude and abundance in our lives.

The next step, is to share the immense wealth (spiritual, knowledge-based) with this chunk of so-called prosperous populace so they can TRULY celebrate life.

Jai Gurudev
(Maintain Innocence, Cultivate Intelligence)

Unknown said...

Yep Gaurav...maintaining innocence and staying free

ShareThis